Newly minted Premier Kathy Dunderdale from her 20 Questions interview in the Telegram, December 24, 2010:
Still, Dunderdale maintains being premier was never on her radar.
She says she’s not the kinds of person who envisions things 10 years down the road, but prefers to live in the now.
“If you live your life more in the moment, the rest of it will work its way out.”
-srbp-
Mr. Speaker, if the members opposite think that the level of scrutiny that we do over a $3 billion expenditure in health care is to take every single health authority and work down line by line by line through every piece of that, I do not know what they are thinking over there.
Health and community services minister Susan Sullivan, House of Assembly, May 30, 2012
Let’s hope that health minister Susan Sullivan doesn’t sit on the treasury board.
That’s a committee of cabinet created under the Financial Administration Act. Passed by the House of Assembly in 1973, the Financial Administration Act was one of several great reforms of public administration in the province introduced by the Conservatives after they defeated Joe Smallwood and the Liberals in the 1972 general election.
Every provincial government and the federal government has a treasury board. It is typically the most important or one of the most important cabinet committee by virtue of its control over money and people within government. Treasury board is also the only cabinet committee whose existence is set down by law.
The treasury board’s main job is to oversee how the provincial government and its agencies spend public money.
As often as they say it, the facts don’t bear out the claim some politician like to make about the provincial public debt.
The Premier did it again in the House of Assembly Tuesday evening. We can all give her a bit of a break since she was on her feet and obvious her blood was up.
But still, this is an old claim that is as false now as it was when the Tories first started using it a few years ago. And frankly, Kathy Dunderdale should have a better grasp of the facts. Otherwise what some people think is visionary leadership is just another delusional politician on a rant. Heaven knows our province has been saddled with enough of those.
If the provincial government can actually get control on its spending and head down the road to management reform along the lines that Eastern Health’s Vicki Kaminski talked about on Tuesday, then they are headed down the right road.
Basic public relations problem.
Say one thing.
Say another thing.
A few weeks later, do something else, twice over.
For starters, here’s the what Premier Kathy Dunderdale said in the House of Assembly in March about job cuts and the provincial budget:
Here’s what Premier Kathy Dunderdale said on March 6 about possible job cuts in the provincial public sector (emphasis added in all):
Mr. Speaker, we have not talked about cuts….Front-line health and education services will be exempted.
Here’s what education minister Clyde Jackman said on March 29:
I spoke at an NLTA meeting a little while ago; I said to them, we are looking at our budgets across departments, but the Premier said there will be no frontline cuts.
And then there’s what health minister Susan Sullivan said on May 28, the day before Eastern health’s planned announcement:
Mr. Speaker, our resolve has not changed. There will not be any cuts in programs and services. The announcement that you will hear tomorrow will lay out some particular initiatives that Eastern Health wishes to embark upon, but we have made our commitment firm to the people of Newfoundland and Labrador; there will not be cuts in programs and services, Mr. Speaker.
Do those words all mean the same thing?
-srbp-
For those getting ready for this afternoon’s announcement by Eastern Health, here are some figures from Statistics Canada on employment in the health care sector in the province from October 2003 to December 2011.
A new poll by CROP (via Paul Wells) shows that Quebeckers support having students at Quebec’s post-secondary colleges and universities pay more for their education.
What’s more, they think that the law which tries to force protesting students back to class is a bad idea.
Take these results together and we begin to see the wisdom of crowds — not the ones in the street, necessarily, but of the whole population. Opinions are divided, but in the main, Quebecers:
• think it is more legitimate to ask students to contribute more to their education than to say they have paid enough.
• believe Law 78 asks for things a government should be able to ask of its citizens — i.e., that it’s a legitimate law;
• don’t think Law 78 will make student refuseniks more likely to cough up their tuition money — i.e., they don’t think it’s a pertinent law.
About 30 years ago, Kathy Dunderdale started out her political career fighting against fisheries reform.
Last December, she scolded fish plant workers in Marystown for turning out 18 weeks work that would have qualified them for employment insurance and kept their plant open.
She continued her fight against fisheries reform over the weekend in a series of interviews with national media about the federal government’s proposed changes to the employment insurance system.
Premier Kathy Dunderdale should appoint municipal affairs minister Kevin “Fairity” O’Brien to handle intergovernmental affairs.
While Dunderdale is busily lobbing hand grenades at the federal government, Fairity is taking a very different attitude:
In a scrum on Wednesday, May 23, Premier Kathy Dunderdale said:
“What we are talking about, in fact, is a two hour window here.”
In the House of Assembly on Thursday, May 24, Premier Kathy Dunderdale said:
I have asked Minister MacKay for an explanation of the gap that occurred on January 30 in the search when there was a five-hour period that they were not engaged in the search. The answers are not satisfactory; the protocols need to be changed.
There is no five-hour period in the Burton Winters search that matches whatever Kathy Dunderdale is talking about in that exchange in the House of Assembly. In fact, it’s pretty hard for anyone with even a sketchy knowledge of the events in Makkovik in late January and early February to figure out what Kathy Dunderdale is getting on with.
“In the fishery of the very near future,” SRBP wrote in February, “fishing subsidies like federal employment insurance wage subsidies, state-sponsored marketing schemes and the stalinist political control of the economy… will all go by the wayside. International trade talks are already laying the groundwork for massive change.”
The very near future arrived this week.
In an interview with CBC’s David Cochrane, federal intergovernmental affairs minister Peter Penashue called Premier Kathy Dunderdale’s bluff about a public inquiry into the death of Burton Winters.
Penashue said:
"This is a legally initiated process and everyone would have to co-operate."
Dunderdale has criticised the federal government over Winters’ death. That’s despite Dunderdale acknowledging – eventually – that provincial officials had responsibility for conducting the search for Winters when he went missing. As recently as Tuesday, Dunderdale continued to try and smear Winters’ blood on federal officials.
Municipal affairs minister Kevin “Fairity” O’Brien stood in the House of Assembly on Wednesday “to highlight the continued progress in implementing the Provincial Waste Management Strategy in our province.”
Wonderful stuff it could have been.
The only problem is Fairity really didn’t provide an update.
Via Monkey Cage comes a link to a study that shows that the average speech comprehension level in the United States Congress has dropped a full grade level in the past seven years. It’s dropped to 10.6 from 11.5.
Over the past 16 years, the Republicans and Democrats have traded places when it comes to scoring lower grade levels on the comprehension scale. The party scores were never more than 0.2 or 0.4 apart, but since 2006, the Republicans score lower than the Democrats.
Political leaders have a moral duty to the people they serve.
There are times for politicians to fight for their constituents.
And there are times when responsible political leaders must help a community to heal. In the wake of the tragedy in Makkovik, Premier Kathy Dunderdale should be helping people to come to terms with a tragedy. Instead, the Premier is abusing people who have put their trust in her to do the right thing.
A few days ago, Stephen Taylor posted a table from a 2010 study that showed how big Quebec’s public debt is compared to that of countries around the world.
The results weren’t pretty.
A similar comparison for Newfoundland and Labrador isn’t pretty either.
